Journal Ethics and Permission

Publication Ethics
General Declaration

Depiction of Health adheres to the "ethical standards for publication" to ensure upon the "high-quality scientific publications", which grants the public trust for the scientific findings as the proof-of-concept and the proof-of-transformative technology.
Depiction of Health follows Helsinki Declaration.

Plagiarism, Duplicated Publication, Data Fabrication and Falsification

DOH is committed to publish the original studies and recent reviews that have not already been submitted to other journals and is not under review elsewhere. All submitted manuscripts (MSs) to DOH are carefully scrutinized for plagiarism. The plagiarized materials will incur the “Plagiarism Sanctions”. Such cases as redundant publication, translation to other languages and other journals without permission are subjected to research misconduct.
Submitted MSs, which are found to be published or under review elsewhere, will be sustained and experience the “Duplicated Publication Sanctions”.
Submitted MSs, which are found to include either fabricated or falsified data including the manipulation of images, will confront with the “Data Fabrication/Falsification Sanctions”. (Plagiarism Policy)

Redundant Publications
All the redundant publications, which are involved in an inappropriate dividing of study outcomes into several articles, will face with the “Redundant Publication Sanctions”.

Citation Manipulation
All the submitted MSs found to have manipulated citations primarily for just increasing the number of citations to a given author(s) or article(s) will incur the “Citation Manipulation Sanctions”.

Gift Authorship
All listed authors are require to have significant scientific contributions to the research of the submitted MS and also approved the claimed findings. Gift Authorship, an author without any significant scientific contribution, will meet with the “Gift Authorship Sanctions”.
According to the ICMJE, the authorship should be based on the following criteria:
•    Substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work, or the acquisition, analysis or interpretation of data.
•    Drafting the work or revising it critically for important intellectual content.
•    Final approval of the version published.
•    Agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work in ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved.

Based on the COPE guidelines, DOH will consider retracting a publication if:
•    It has clear evidence that the findings are unreliable, either as a result of misconduct (e.g. data fabrication) or honest error (e.g. miscalculation or experimental error).
•    The findings have previously been published elsewhere without proper cross-referencing, permission or justification (i.e. cases of redundant publication)
•    It constitutes plagiarism.
•    It reports unethical research.

In the case of occurrence documented violations of the aforementioned policies of Depiction of Health, it is the DOH’s right to apply the following sanctions:
•    DOH keeps all the rights to retract the infringing published works at any time found based on the COPE guideline for retracting articles.
•    Immediate rejection of the infringing manuscript and sanction of the infringed author(s).
•    Prohibition against all the authors for any new submissions to DOH for a minimum of 24 months.
•    Prohibition against all the infringed authors from serving as a reviewer of acting as a member of the Editorial Board of DOH for a minimum of 36 months.
•    In cases of occurrence of violations found to be particularly ostensible, DOH reserves the right to apply additional sanctions beyond the aforementioned actions.

 Academic dishonesty
 Suspected redundant (duplicate) publication a submitted manuscript (PDF, 60 kb) and in a published article (PDF, 84 kb)
Suspected plagiarism in a submitted manuscript (PDF, 80 kb) and in a published article (PDF, 76 kb)
Suspect fabricated data in a submitted manuscript (PDF, 84 kb) and in a published article (PDF, 84 kb)

          Request for addition of extra author before (PDF, 52 kb) or after publication (PDF, 68 kb)
          Request for removal of author before publication (PDF, 52 kb)
          Request for removal of author Suspected guest, ghost or gift authorship (PDF, 76 kb)
          Advice on how to spot authorship problems (PDF, 64 kb)

 Conflict of Interests (CoI)
          If a reviewer suspects undisclosed conflict of interest in a submitted manuscript (PDF, 56 kb)
          If a reader suspects undisclosed conflict of interest in a published article (PDF, 56 kb)

Other considerations
          If we suspect an ethical problem with a submitted manuscript (PDF, 68 kb)
          If we suspect a reviewer has appropriated an author’s idea or data (PDF, 88 kb)
          How COPE handles complaints against editors (PDF, 68 kb)

Everyone could receive complete set of flowcharts (PDF, 476 kb)